| 1964- | Ivan E. Merrick, Jr. (St Patrick) |
| 1964-1967 | Edward R. Caldwell (St Hilda) |
| Brian F. Nurding (St Patrick) | |
| Charles B. Atcheson (St Patrick) | |
| St Hilda & St Patrick Merge | |
| 1967- | David A. Storm |
| 1972-1984 | Thomas A. Goman |
| 1974-1974 | John B. Vance |
| 1974-1977 | James E. Price |
| 1977-1981 | Joseph J. Tiernau |
| 1982-1987 | Marianne Bogel |
| 1988-1998 | Paul M. Collins |
| 2000-2001 | Douglas C. Simonsen |
| 2001-2008 | Peter Snow |
| 2008-2017 | Cynthia A. Espeseth |
| 2017-2018 | Mark Miller |
| 2018-2019 | Sabeth Fitzgibbons (Interim) |
| 2019-2025 | Joseph Peters-Mathews (Vicar) |
